$The Offer Guide
← HOW-TO LIBRARY
CASHBACK

New vs existing customer cashback rates

The highest rate can be restricted to new customers. Check the definition before comparing it with your own purchase.

1Merchant customer history
2Correct rate category
3Saved category terms
CompareChoose the exact route
QualifyFollow its conditions
CollectWait for approval

Check advertiser history

Read whether previous accounts, orders, subscriptions, or household activity affect eligibility. A new portal account does not necessarily make you a new customer of the merchant.

Choose the correct category

A portal can show separate rates for new and existing customers, products, or order types. Compare the rate for your actual route. Do not apply a first-order headline to a renewal without explicit support in the terms.

Keep the qualifying wording

Save the relevant category and exclusions before purchase. If a lower rate tracks, check whether the merchant classified your order differently before opening a missing-credit inquiry.

WORKED EXAMPLE

Example: a portal lists 15% for new customers and 3% for existing customers. An existing eligible $100 order corresponds to $3, not $15.

Explore saved examples

Catalogue examples, not verified current payout promises. Confirm the reward and full conditions in your account.

ExpressVPNTopCashbackCompare →Walkthrough →
Keeper SecurityTopCashbackCompare →Walkthrough →
Private Internet AccessTopCashbackCompare →Walkthrough →

Keep exploring

Before you commit

Merchant customer history

Read whether previous accounts, orders, subscriptions, or household activity affect eligibility. A new portal account does not necessarily make you a new customer of the merchant.

Correct rate category

A portal can show separate rates for new and existing customers, products, or order types. Compare the rate for your actual route. Do not apply a first-order headline to a renewal without explicit support in the terms.

Saved category terms

Save the relevant category and exclusions before purchase. If a lower rate tracks, check whether the merchant classified your order differently before opening a missing-credit inquiry.

Sources and terms: TopCashback explanation · Rakuten tracking guidance · CFPB bank account guidance. Advertiser-specific conditions take precedence.